UberX and UberBLACK Drivers Are Not Employees for Purposes of the NLRA
According to the NLRB General Counsel’s Division of Advice (GC), Uber’s UberX and UberBLACK drivers are independent contractors exempt from the rights and protections of the National Labor Relations Act (NLRA), including the right to form and join unions. Advice Memo, dated April 16 2019, Uber Technologies, Inc., Case Nos. 13-CA-163062, 14-CA-158833 and 29-CA-177483. Applying the National Labor Relations Board’s (Board or NLRB) traditional multi-factored common law agency test used to determine whether workers are employees or independent contractors and after considering all of the common law factors through the “prism of entrepreneurial opportunity” as mandated by the Board’s recent decision in Supershuttle DFW, Inc., 367 NLRB No. 75 (January 25, 2019), the GC has found that the drivers were independent contractors and not employees within the meaning of the NLRA.
The GC also considered and then discounted certain factors often relied upon to establish a worker’s employee status, finding them not dispositive indicators of employee status. For instance, in the GC’s view, the fact that Uber received a percentage of a driver’s fare instead of charging a driver a flat fee for their use of the Company’s ride sharing platform did not support a finding of employee status because the fundamental features of the Uber system including Uber’s reliance on customer reviews to maintain quality and insure repeat business without the need for company control overcame any inference of employer control or the diminution of a driver’s entrepreneurial opportunity. Likewise, the fact that no special skills or experience were required to qualify a driver to use the Uber platform and that the driver’s work was integral to Uber’s business did not mandate a finding of employee status, citing prior Board decisions in which individuals were held to be independent contractors, even though their services were integral to the business of the company that engaged them, given the entrepreneurial opportunity afforded them. Continue Reading